"Who says we're going to break up?" Alex asked, which maybe was unreasonable - almost every couple broke up - but he asked it reasonably, like he really believed it would work. Because he sort of did.
Other options:
no subject
"Who says we're going to break up?" Alex asked, which maybe was unreasonable - almost every couple broke up - but he asked it reasonably, like he really believed it would work. Because he sort of did.